How We Review Supplements (Our 100-Point Evaluation Framework)

Supplement Review Report is an independent consumer education website. This page explains exactly how we review supplements, how our scoring system works, and what a supplement score does and does not mean.

Important: We do not provide medical advice. We do not diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. Our scoring system evaluates publicly available product information and marketing practices — not medical outcomes.

For official consumer guidance on dietary supplements, see the FDA’s resource here: FDA: Information for Consumers on Using Dietary Supplements .

Our Independent Review Philosophy

Many supplement review websites focus primarily on promotion. Our goal is different. We evaluate transparency, marketing clarity, and consumer accountability signals that buyers can verify before purchasing.

We believe consumers deserve clear labeling, responsible marketing language, and straightforward refund policies.

Our 100-Point Supplement Scoring System

Every supplement is scored out of 100 points using the same structured framework. A higher score generally means the product provides clearer information, uses more responsible marketing language, and offers stronger consumer accountability indicators.

A lower score usually means product information is unclear, marketing is overly aggressive, or refund and company details are difficult to verify.

1) Transparency

0–25

How clearly the product is described, how easy it is to verify basic details, and whether key information is accessible.

2) Ingredient Disclosure

0–25

Whether ingredients and dosages are clearly listed. Hidden or vague blends reduce clarity.

3) Marketing Honesty

0–25

We evaluate exaggerated promises, urgency pressure tactics, fake endorsements, and disease-related implications.

4) Company Accountability

0–25

Whether the company is identifiable and reachable, and whether refund, billing, and support policies are clear.

What Our Supplement Scores Mean

90–100: Strong transparency and accountability signals.
75–89: Generally clear information with minor concerns.
60–74: Noticeable clarity or marketing issues.
Below 60: Significant transparency or accountability concerns.

What We Evaluate in Every Review

Label clarity: ingredient list, dosage details, supplement facts visibility.
Sales page claims: exaggerated language, miracle claims, urgency pressure.
Company identity: contact methods, physical address, support accessibility.
Refund policy: clear terms, billing transparency, and cancellation ease.
Advertising patterns: fake news layouts or misleading “breakthrough” positioning.

What We Do Not Claim

We do not claim that any supplement treats or cures a disease.
We do not claim that a high score equals medical effectiveness.
We do not claim that a low score means a product is illegal.
We do not claim results will be the same for every individual.

Why We Publish Low Scores

Transparency matters. We include lower-scoring reviews because consumers often learn the most from seeing clear examples of labeling gaps, aggressive marketing language, or unclear refund practices.

Affiliate Disclosure

Some reviews may include affiliate links. If you purchase through a link, we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Affiliate relationships do not change our scoring methodology.

Corrections & Updates

Product pages and policies change over time. If you believe information is outdated, please contact us with the product link and specific detail.

Contact: su*****@********************rt.com